Reviews For Chiseled in Stone
You must login (register) to review.
Reviewer: ladyevenstar Signed [Report This]
Date: 02/12/12 - 10:09 am Title: Epilogue

that was... *sniff sniff* beautiful it was so touching... it almost made me want to cry

Reviewer: Irial Signed [Report This]
Date: 13/04/11 - 10:52 am Title: Epilogue

An absolutely delightful alternate ending. Well written, well done - Iri

Author's Response: Thank you very much Irial!:):):):) ~~~~~{~@

Reviewer: threaderofink Signed [Report This]
Date: 31/01/11 - 06:44 pm Title: Chapter 1

An incredibly touching story! usually it's hard to imagine that our little heroes didn't survive, since i am fond of them,But i think that it is very likely that there would be a monument for them if they didn't get out alive, a tribute to their sacrifice. brilliant original characters are very believable and the AU isn't very overpowering. i liked the background story to the sculptor and the handmaiden was endearing. overall great job.

Author's Response: Thanks for your comments threaderofink! So glad you like the story. It's my first LotR fanfic and I knew the premise was a bit daring...but I decided to go with it anyway. Yes, there should definitely be a monument, shouldn't there? It's wonderful you like the OC's, I enjoy them as well. Thanks once more!

Reviewer: meerkatalex Signed [Report This]
Date: 05/06/08 - 10:13 am Title: Epilogue

This story is so nice; I never thought that there may be a monument for Frodo and Sam if they had died. Lovely.

Author's Response: Thanks meerkatalex; somehow I didn't get this comment before and just now saw it. Glad you like the story and thanks for commenting! Yes, there would have to be a monument, wouldn't there? Thanks again! ~~~~~{~@

Reviewer: Nazgrrl Signed [Report This]
Date: 17/01/08 - 05:10 pm Title: Epilogue

Oh, I love this.

You have the perfect voice for telling a story like this, and the AU is not overpowering.

SMEE

Author's Response: Thank you Smee! Glad you liked it. Thanks for commenting!rnrn~~~~{~@

Reviewer: elven lily Signed [Report This]
Date: 24/07/07 - 04:21 pm Title: Chapter 1

This was a very nice story, aren't we glad that Frodo and Sam were rescued by the eagles! I know I am. I was glad that you didn't go any further with the relationship between Arwen and the sculptor, as I would have a very difficult time seeing Arwen having an affair, she and Aragorn are too much in love! ;) I really liked it and thought that it was very cute, especially the thought of Frodo as a glowing, smiling spirit! Keep up the good work!

Author's Response: Why thanks, Dearie! Yes, very glad indeed! But on a message board I used to visit someone asked the question, "What if the eagles had NOT come?" and I puzzled over this until I just had to write a story answering it! Yes, an affair would have been out of the question, I'm sure, at least for this kind of story. And just had to work Frodo into it somehow! So glad you liked it, and thanks so much for the feedback! ~~~~{~@

You must login (register) to review.