Reviews For A Test of Faith
You must login (register) to review.
Reviewer: LegolasxAnariel Signed [Report This]
Date: 27/06/12 - 10:45 am Title: Chapter 3

I like your story a lot, but i have some criticisms. Your character Amandra seems to be a bit of a marry-sue. In other words she seems way to perfect. I mean, she's related to a king, she's a skilled warrior, she can talk to animals, she's aquaimted with Legolas, so on. Also, when she told Legolas to kiss an Orc, she wasn't speaking in his native language, because in fotr, when there were orcs he said "yrch" or something like that and Tolkien said that he said it in his native tongue. But I like the story. This is the first fanfiction I've read about haldir, as he is not one of my favorite characters. Legolas, Aragorn, and Frodo are, in that order. Bit it is a good story so far.

Author's Response: I appreciate your honest input and appraisal. Obviously this story is quite old. I do defend the fact that she knows Legolas as a byproduct of her being related to Aragorn. I was drawing on a desire to remember that Aragorn had a life before he went to live with the Elves, though I confess that was very loosely interpreted by me, as I have not read anything about just how old Aragorn was when he was brought to Elrond. There is truly no way to win with original female characters. If they are too frail and dependent, they are MarySue. If they are too capable, they are MarySue. I like this story, and I confess to reading Robert Jordan's Wheel of time, almost non-stop since 1996 and the man loved to write incredibly strong, independent, beautiful, talented and strong women who were not at all MarySue. At any rate, I am still reading WoT and am considering going with the AU spin I was heading for on this one. If I can find the time to write again! Thanks for reading and for your input.

Reviewer: Erato Signed [Report This]
Date: 12/03/12 - 06:49 am Title: Chapter 3

A wonderful Story!!!!
Why on earth did you not Continued it?????

Reviewer: Luthien of Lorien Signed [Report This]
Date: 01/02/12 - 09:57 pm Title: Chapter 3

i am so sad right now, that there is no chapter 4, please, is there any chance to see more of this great story? maybe in another board? greetings!

Reviewer: Migdaliafr Signed [Report This]
Date: 16/09/11 - 09:55 pm Title: Chapter 3

Do they meet again? And where was she? Why was she traveling so fast for?

Reviewer: Daeliltha Signed [Report This]
Date: 05/04/11 - 07:39 pm Title: Chapter 3

I love this story so far. Please continue with it. Haldir is one of my favorite characters and I've always been upset that he, nor Legolas found love. Maybe you'll give that to one of them... Or both?


Reviewer: LadyConfidential Signed [Report This]
Date: 03/05/10 - 08:13 am Title: Chapter 3

I very much enjoyed this story so far. It was written well, and portrayed the characters in line with how Tolkien wrote them. I hope you will continue this story soon :)

Reviewer: Luna Signed [Report This]
Date: 15/01/09 - 02:26 am Title: Chapter 3

I know you said you were rethinking the story, but I really like it so far!! Anything with Haldir is fantastic and having her be Aragorn's cousin is a fun fit.


Reviewer: Devonshirelass Signed [Report This]
Date: 18/04/08 - 07:11 pm Title: Chapter 3

Haha! Would never have thought that! Aaragorn has a cousin! I also see the green eyed monster is rearing its ugly head! - Jealousy always poses problems! I enjoyed reading this chapter very much!

Reviewer: Devonshirelass Signed [Report This]
Date: 18/04/08 - 06:59 pm Title: Chapter 2

Aww! That was a sad chapter, the poor horse! Again, another great read which draws you straight into the story! I look forward to reading the next chapter...

Reviewer: Devonshirelass Signed [Report This]
Date: 18/04/08 - 06:47 pm Title: Chapter 1

I liked this, and look forward to reading more...

Reviewer: Lady Annalease Signed [Report This]
Date: 09/11/07 - 01:39 am Title: Chapter 1

Love the story! Are you going to finish it?

Reviewer: Blue eyed Heretic Signed [Report This]
Date: 18/04/07 - 07:28 pm Title: Chapter 1

Haldir and Legolas are the most awesomest characters ever, and both of them in the same story is even more awesomest! You're a very good writer with useing new words and being very descriptive, also, I haven't seen any grammar errors! Yay! ^_^
Update soon, kay?

Reviewer: sonnet white Signed [Report This]
Date: 16/02/07 - 01:10 am Title: Chapter 3

I have to admit, I love the "commanding" Haldir. *drools* You write excellently. Amandra's connection to Aragorn is a nice twist. You have a good way with names in this fic...very Tolkienish. Keep up the good work!

Reviewer: Weffles Signed [Report This]
Date: 28/01/07 - 09:21 pm Title: Chapter 3

I love this story, you write brilliantly, so please UPDATE!!!

Reviewer: aranel1 Signed [Report This]
Date: 02/01/07 - 06:42 pm Title: Chapter 1

Extremely well written. I admire your talent. It certainly surpasses mine.


Reviewer: elfenears Signed [Report This]
Date: 31/12/06 - 10:55 am Title: Chapter 2

ooo can't wait to read more
this is a good start i love haldir fic's

You must login (register) to review.